3 min read

Should we sell the inherited house to an investor, on the MLS, or off the MLS?

Should we sell the inherited house to an investor, on the MLS, or off the MLS?

Usually on the MLS. A listing there is the best auction there is: every active buyer sees the house at once, investors included, and they compete. Off the MLS, the house is offered with a published price and a set window, with more privacy and control, and an attractive house can still draw several buyers at once. A single investor offer is the fastest and least work, but it's a market of one. Compare what the estate keeps under each, how long each takes, and how much work each asks of the family.

After a death, families often get letters and calls offering cash for the house, as-is, fast. Any of those buyers can be the right buyer, and I'm agnostic about who buys the house. What sets the price is how many buyers are competing for it.

The three routes

Single investor offer On the MLS Off the MLS
Who competesNo one. One buyer, one priceEvery active buyer at once, investors includedBuyers brought by agents and direct marketing, usually one at a time, sometimes several at once
How the price is setThe buyer works backward from its resale plan and profitBuyers competing in the first days on the marketNegotiation against a published price and a deadline, or competition when several buyers want it
SpeedFastestUsually weeks once it's listedA set window you choose
Work for the familyLeast. Sold as-isClearing and preparation, unless it's listed as-is, plus showingsThe same preparation, with fewer showings
PrivacyHighLow. Price and days on market are publicHigh. No public days-on-market count
CostsThe buyer's margin, and any fees and repair deductionsCommission, any preparation, and carrying costsCommission, any preparation, and carrying costs
CertaintyDepends on the contract. Watch the walk-away termsDepends on the buyer's financing and contingenciesDepends on the buyer's financing and contingencies

A single investor offer

Should I take a cash offer from Opendoor or another home-buying company? covers how these offers are priced, the fees and repair deductions, the contract terms that let a buyer walk away or assign the deal, and the questions to ask. All of it applies to an estate.

An estate adds one more reason for caution. The executor answers to every heir, and a single offer taken without exposing the house to the market is hard to justify to the others. Should we sell the inherited house as-is? explains why.

On the MLS: the best auction there is

On the MLS, every active buyer sees the house at once, and the first days work like an auction: buyers compete before the listing ages. The field includes the same investors and flippers who send the postcards, alongside owner-occupants and renovators who don't need a profit margin. The family sets the terms.

The trade-off is that everything is public. The price and the days on market are visible, and if the house sits, everyone can see it. A house that needs work can still go on the market as it is. As-is describes the condition, not the way it's sold.

Off the MLS

Off the MLS, the house is offered with a published price for a set window, and agents bring their buyers. They usually come one at a time, but a well-priced, attractive house can draw several at once, and the window gives them a reason to compete. There's no public days-on-market count, and each showing brings feedback on the price and the house. It suits a family that values privacy, wants to test what the house will bring as it is before spending on it, or wants to set its own timeline. If the window closes without the right offer, the house can still go on the MLS. On-MLS vs Off-MLS compares the two markets in detail.

When each fits

  • Investor. The house needs major work, the heirs want it finished quickly, no one can manage the house, and the family has seen what the market would bring.
  • On the MLS. The house is prepared, or priced for its condition, and the family wants every buyer competing at once.
  • Off the MLS. The family values privacy, wants to learn what the house will bring before investing in it, or has its own timeline.

What the family is optimizing for

No family simply wants top dollar. Every route costs time, effort, and money, and how much the result matters multiplies all three. An estate with heirs in three states and a house that needs a roof weighs those differently than an estate with a local executor and a well-kept house. What does it cost the estate to carry the house each month until it sells? helps put a number on the time.

Get more than one number

Before choosing, get a Home Audit and a seller net sheet for selling the house as it is and after modest preparation. Put any investor offer next to them, with its terms, and compare what the estate keeps after costs and carrying time.

The executor's duty

The executor or trustee is selling for the heirs, not for themselves. Document the routes you considered, the numbers behind each, and why you chose one. That record matters most when the heirs don't agree. What if the heirs don't agree about selling? covers that case.

This is general information, not legal advice. An executor or trustee has legal duties to the heirs. Before choosing how to sell, confirm the decision and how to document it with the estate's attorney.

For more on how I approach each kind of move, see Rightsizing, Retirement, Helping a Parent, and Estate Sales.

Start a conversation

Does my house have to be perfect to sell while I'm living in it?

Does my house have to be perfect to sell while I'm living in it?

Selling your Northern Virginia home while you live in it? It doesn't have to be perfect. What buyers expect, how to set a showing schedule, and on vs...

Read More
A Market, Not The Market

A Market, Not The Market

Why the MLS is one market among several, how its weekly auction works, what days on market and price history really signal, and how sellers choose a...

Read More
Should I take a cash offer from Opendoor or another home-buying company?

Should I take a cash offer from Opendoor or another home-buying company?

Got a cash offer from Opendoor or a "we buy houses" company for your Northern Virginia home? Every offer pays cash at closing. Compare net price and...

Read More