Should we sell Mom's house or rent it out?
Parent moving out of a Northern Virginia home? How selling compares with renting it out on cash for care, landlord work, the home sale exclusion, and...
5 min read
David Zadareky : Published
Every offer is a cash offer by the time you get to closing. Whether the buyer uses a mortgage or their own money, you receive cash at settlement. "Cash" describes where the buyer's money comes from, not what you're paid. The two things to compare are your net price, what you keep after every fee and deduction, and the terms: how firm the offer is and how easily the buyer can walk away.
If you own a home in Northern Virginia, you've probably had the postcard, the text, or the email: We'll buy your house for cash. No repairs, no showings, close when you want. Some come from national companies like Opendoor. Others come from local investors. The word doing the work in that pitch is "cash," and it's a distraction.
At settlement, a financed buyer's lender wires the loan to the title company, the buyer adds their down payment, and the title company pays you. A cash buyer skips the lender. Either way, the money that lands in your account is the same kind of money.
What a cash offer is supposed to change is the risk between contract and closing. A buyer with no loan has no financing contingency, no lender appraisal, and no underwriting to wait on, so the sale can close sooner and is less likely to fall through. Those are real advantages, but they're terms, and a financed buyer can offer many of the same ones: a short financing contingency, an appraisal waiver or gap coverage, a large deposit, a fast settlement date.
Many cash buyers are borrowing. The money may come from a hard-money lender, a line of credit, or outside investors. The difference is that they haven't mentioned it, and the contract isn't contingent on their getting it. If their money falls through, you find out at closing.
Ask where the money is coming from, and ask for proof of funds: a recent bank or brokerage statement, or a letter from the lender, showing enough to close. A buyer who won't provide it is telling you something.
The offer price is the least useful number in an investor offer. What matters is what's left after the buyer's fees and deductions.
The buyer's profit. A company buying your house to resell it, rent it, or sell the contract to another investor works backward from that plan. It starts with what it expects to resell the house for, then subtracts repairs, the cost of holding and reselling, and the profit it wants. What's left is your offer. That margin comes out of your equity. A buyer who plans to live in the house doesn't need a profit margin to buy it from you.
The service fee. iBuyers like Opendoor charge a service fee that varies by home and market. It's listed in the offer breakdown.
The repair deduction. After the inspection, the buyer deducts its own estimate of what the house needs. You don't see the contractor bids behind it. In my experience, buyers estimate repairs high, and a buyer who's reselling has every reason to.
Everything else. You still pay your share of closing costs. Read the fee schedule for charges for staying past closing, leaving belongings behind, or cleaning. Local "we buy houses" companies often charge no stated fee at all. Their cost is built into a lower price.
The default provision. Read this part of the contract first. It says what happens if the buyer doesn't close. Some investor contracts limit your only remedy to keeping the deposit, or let the buyer cancel by giving notice. Paired with a small deposit, that language lets the buyer walk away for any reason, at almost no cost, at any point before closing. You've taken your house off the market for an option the buyer holds and you don't.
The inspection or due-diligence period. Most investor contracts give the buyer a week or more to inspect and walk away. Until it ends, the offer isn't firm, whatever the word "cash" suggests.
The re-price. The buyer contracts to buy your house at one price, inspects it, and comes back with a lower one. By then you've stopped talking to anyone else and may have planned your move around the closing date.
The right to assign. Some contracts let the buyer assign the contract to another investor, usually for a fee and without your approval. The company you signed with may never buy your house, and you may not know who will until closing.
The deposit. The smaller it is, the less the buyer loses by walking away.
Settlement and possession. Check who sets the settlement date, whether you can stay in the house after closing, and whether you have to leave it clear of trash, debris, and personal belongings.
If your house needs work, you have four ways to sell it. Each one ends in cash at closing.
1. Sell to a company like Opendoor. These companies mostly buy homes that need little work, so a house with major repairs may not get an offer. When it does, the offer starts near what the house would be worth fixed up. Then the company subtracts a service fee and its own estimate of the repairs. In return, you get no showings, no preparation, and a closing date you choose.
2. Sell to a professional flipper. There's usually no stated fee and no repair deduction. The flipper's renovation, holding costs, resale commissions, and profit are built into the price, which is often around 70% of what the house will sell for once it's renovated.
3. List the house as it is. The house goes in front of every buyer looking for a project: do-it-yourselfers willing to take on the work to get into the neighborhood, and flippers, who now have to compete with those buyers and with each other.
4. Fix it up before you sell. You spend the money and the time on the work, and you keep the profit margin a flipper would have taken.
There's no right or wrong answer. The best option depends on what the work would cost, what it would add to the price, how much time you have, and how much effort you're willing to put in. The math behind a Home Audit shows which option comes out ahead for your house. What should I fix before I list? explains how that math works.
None of this is a case against Opendoor, flippers, or any company that buys homes this way. Any of them can be the right buyer, and I'm agnostic about who buys your house. What matters is how many buyers are competing for it. When there's only one possible buyer, that buyer doesn't have to compete. With no competition, the price ends up lower than what you might otherwise have gotten. That's why selling to a market of one won't bring the most your house can sell for.
These are the same questions to ask of any offer, cash or financed.
Get any investor's offer in writing, with every fee and deduction, and the contract itself. Then get a Home Audit and a seller net sheet for listing the house as it is and after the work. Put them side by side, with the terms of each. I can give you the audit and the net sheets, and you can request an investor offer and still decide to list.
This is general information, not legal advice. Any offer is a binding contract once you sign it. Before you sign, have your own attorney review the terms, especially the default provision and any right to assign or walk away.
For more on how I approach each kind of move, see Rightsizing, Retirement, Helping a Parent, and Estate Sales.
Parent moving out of a Northern Virginia home? How selling compares with renting it out on cash for care, landlord work, the home sale exclusion, and...
Selling a parent’s house in Northern Virginia? Compare selling as-is, targeted improvements, and renovation based on cost, timing, and your family’s...
Selling your Northern Virginia home in retirement? How renting compares with buying again on cost, flexibility, equity, and the expense of moving...