Stay if your house, and your life around it, can work for the years ahead with changes you're willing to make and pay for. Move if staying depends on changes the house can't take, or on help you don't want to rely on. Either way, decide while it's still your choice, not after a fall or a diagnosis decides for you.
Most people I talk with want to stay in their home as long as they can. The real question is whether your health, the house, the neighborhood and your finances will let you, and what it will cost to make it work.
Start with an ordinary Tuesday
Before you think about the house, think about your life. Where do you want to be, and what do you want to be doing on any random Tuesday? Who's nearby? How far is the drive to the doctor, the grocery store, church, your friends? And if you stopped driving, could you still get to those places?
A house that works can still be in the wrong place. If your friends have moved, your children live three states away, and every errand takes a car, staying can get lonely even in a perfect house.
Weigh both paths the same way
I look at any move, and any decision to stay, as (Time + Effort + Money) × Importance.
- Staying takes time managing contractors and caregivers, the effort of upkeep, and money for changes, repairs and help.
- Moving takes time and effort to sort, sell and settle somewhere new, and money for selling and buying.
- Importance is how much each one matters to you: staying near neighbors you've known for decades, or living somewhere with less to manage and more people around.
Can the house keep working for you?
Walk through your home and picture living there with less energy, less balance, or a walker:
- A bedroom and full bathroom on the main floor, or room to add them.
- A step-free way in, or room for a ramp.
- Stairs you'd have to climb every day, including to the laundry.
- Bathrooms where a walk-in shower and grab bars can go.
- Doorways and halls wide enough for a walker or wheelchair.
- Lighting, flooring and the yard, and how much of it you can safely keep up.
An occupational therapist or a certified aging-in-place specialist can walk the house with you and tell you what it would take.
What staying costs
- Changes to the house. Grab bars, railings and better lighting cost little. A first-floor suite, a stair lift or a step-free entrance can cost a great deal and take months.
- The big systems. Roof, heating and cooling, water heater, windows. Some of them will come due while you live there.
- Upkeep. Lawn, snow, gutters, cleaning. Someone has to do it or be paid to.
- Help at home. The national median for a non-medical in-home caregiver was $35 an hour in 2025. At 44 hours a week, that's about $80,000 a year.
- Property taxes. They keep rising. Fairfax, Arlington and Loudoun all offer real estate tax relief for owners 65 and older who meet income and asset limits, and Fairfax also lets eligible owners defer their taxes.
How to pay for staying
- Savings and income, the simplest route.
- A home equity line of credit, opened while your income makes it easy to qualify.
- A reverse mortgage on the home you have. It turns part of your equity into cash without selling. Because you don't sell, you don't realize a capital gain, and the money is a loan, so it isn't taxed as income. The loan comes due if you're away from the home for more than 12 consecutive months, for example in assisted living, and no other borrower lives there. Can I use a reverse mortgage to buy my next home? covers what to think through and watch out for.
What moving costs
- Selling and buying. Agent compensation, transfer taxes and closing costs on the sale, then closing costs on the purchase.
- The work of sorting. Going through a lifetime of belongings is far easier at 70 than at 85, and easier when it's your decision.
- Where you go next. A single-level home, a condo, a 55-plus community or a rental. Should I move to a 55-plus community? and Should I sell and rent, or buy again? cover those choices.
- If care is part of the plan. In Virginia, the median cost of assisted living was about $83,000 a year in 2025, and it runs considerably higher depending on location, features and amenities. In Northern Virginia, I'd expect $100,000 to $180,000 a year. Compare that with what staying with help at home would cost you.
The tax side of staying
For long-time owners, taxes can tilt the math toward staying. If you sell, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for a married couple, and pay tax on the rest. If you keep the home for the rest of your life, your heirs generally inherit it at its value on the date of death, which can wipe out the gain. In Northern Virginia, many long-time owners have gains well above the exclusion. Will I owe capital gains tax when I sell my house? explains how it works. Run those numbers alongside everything else, starting with whether the house still works for you.
Why timing matters
A move you choose is planned. You pick the date, prepare the house, sell it for the best price the market allows, and take your time choosing what's next.
A move made after a health event is usually rushed. A care need and a move-in date set the pace, the house is often sold as-is while family members manage it from a distance, and the decisions get made for you. Helping a Parent shows what that looks like from the family's side.
Financing is also easier while you're still working. Should I sell my house before I retire? covers that timing.
Signs it's time to decide
- The stairs are getting harder.
- You've started putting off repairs.
- You've stopped driving at night, or at all.
- Friends and neighbors have moved away.
- Your children are far away and worry about you.
- Keeping up the house takes more of your week than you'd like.
Any one of these is a good time to make the decision on purpose.
How to decide
- Picture your ordinary Tuesday in the years ahead, and where you want it to happen.
- List the changes the house would want for you to stay, and what they'd cost.
- Get a realistic value and a seller net sheet on the house. I can do that.
- Price two or three places you'd consider moving to. I can do that too.
- Sit down with your financial adviser, tax professional and estate attorney, and compare both paths side by side.
This is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. I'm a real estate broker, not a financial adviser, tax professional or attorney. Tax relief programs, capital gains treatment, reverse mortgages and home equity lines all depend on your circumstances. Before you decide, review your plan with your own financial adviser, tax professional and estate attorney.
For more on how I approach each kind of move, see Rightsizing, Retirement, Helping a Parent, and Estate Sales.
Start a conversation